Friday, May 9, 2008

Trickle-Down Responsibility

When the pictures of American soldiers taunting and humiliating detainees at Abu Ghraib surfaced in 2004, and subsequently the conditions at Guantanamo Bay came under more scrutiny, there was an immediate push to blame any perceived transgressions on "a few bad apples." In other words, sure, there may have been some incidents which crossed a boundary, but it was the effort of a few misguided souls, not a direct result of US policy.

Four years later, it has become increasingly clear that this defense bears little resemblance to the truth. President Bush, himself, recently admitted that he was aware of meetings in the White House held to plan just how far harsh interrogations were allowed to go.

This Thursday, Phillippe Sands met with Amy Goodman to discuss his recent Congressional testimony and added even more evidence to the top-down approach to torture and Guantanamo, in direct contradistinction to the administration's official position.

AMY GOODMAN: Can you talk about the former chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Richard Myers?

PHILLIPPE SANDS: There were two points. Firstly, as everyone knows, the President took a decision that none of the detainees at Guantanamo would have any rights under the Geneva Conventions. It seems that General Myers was unaware of that. He was under the impression they had decided that Geneva would apply...as we went through the techniques of interrogation one by one, that he had thought that these came out of the US Field Manual guide for interrogations. They were all prohibited. And as we went down the list, his jaw literally dropped. So I got the sense that the most powerful military man in the United States, indeed probably in the world, was blissfully unaware of what had been decided.

As Sands inferred from his conversations with Myers, one of the most powerful military men in the world was seemingly unaware of the legal wranglings and positioning going on behind the scenes and above his head. That suggestion syncs with much of the other information regarding questioning at Guantanamo which indicates that most military officers were opposed to the proposed questioning techniques. A large portion of that objection was the belief--well-founded, I think--that violating the Geneva Conventions and the Convention Against Torture would put future American POWs in danger of having the favor returned.

Because of the military commanders' opposition to harsh interrogation techniques, the administration was forced to go above their heads, and the void was filled by the Bush-Cheney legal team.

Part-and-parcel of the upper-echelon approval of torture at Guantanamo and abroad is the political spin campaign by the Pentagon to ensure that public would be unaware of the true scope of the administration's policy of interrogation.

Glenn Greenwald illuminated one such example on Friday, after examining the documents released by the Defense Department.

Greenwald expounds upon the specific case of Gen. Don Shepperd, and analyst employed by CNN, and member of a chaperoned tour of Guantanamo in 2005 designed to persuade the Pentagon's analysts (read: puppets) to present a positive spin in the face of bad publicity. The tour of the facility consumed just under 3 hours. Several pertinent quotes from Shepperd appear in the released documents, one of which summarizes his purpose quite nicely:

Did we drink the government Kool-Aid? Of course, and that was the point.

When he asked how he could help, top Rumsfeld aide Larry Di Rita replied "OK, but let's get him briefed on Khatani so he doesn't go too far on that one" (Third-person because response was via forwarded e-mail.) Khatani was thought to be the 20th hijacker, and considered one of the more egregious breeches of human rights at US facilities.

Shepperd apparently took the hint:

In numerous appearances on CNN talking about Gitmo, no mention was ever made of Khatani or other specific, documented abuses.

When he was finally asked about watching an interrogation, Shepperd assured the viewers that the interrogators could not have been more cordial. Presumably, he expected to be treated to an interrogation indicative of common practices on a PR trip, which could speak to his judgment one would think.

Support of the war has no bearing on finding this program not only immoral, but illegal. Whether one agrees with the war or even cares not about torture should find the elite levels to which the torture program reached and the scope of the Pentagon propaganda campaign alarming.

Sphere: Related Content

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

The True Definition of Backward Science

Nowhere in the industrialized world is science more misunderstood or resented than in the United States. The prevalence of Fundamentalists and other groups have created an environment where scientific theory is presented as on a level with--in both veracity and import--the emotional and irrational biases of untrained citizens.

Some have even taken to classifying science as a 'religion,' as much as reliance on emperical evidence above pure wishes costitutes a religion. There are too many inaccuracies involved in that comparison to ennumerate them all, but for one, when a scientific theory meets contradictory evidence (which is subsequently repeated and reviewed), the theory changes. The corollary to that premise is that conclusions cannot be formed first, and empirical evidence collected later.

Don't tell that to Republicans in the Alaska state legislature, though.

The state Legislature is looking to hire a few good polar bear scientists. The conclusions have already been agreed upon -- researchers just have to fill in the science part.

As far as I can tell, the author wrote this absurdity without a trace of irony or skepticism. Whatever conclusions the lawmakers might want reached (here, the ability to drill for oil devoid of environmental inhibitions), handing over pre-determined conclusions for scientists to sign their name to is antithetical to every standard of scientific integrity.

Science, by its nature, is reliant upon a strict set of standards and procedures, the abandonment of which would invalidate the entire enterprise. Just because some legislators think that facts and empirical evidence are equally valid with pre-ordained conclusions based solely on their whims and ambitions doesn't mean taxpayers should be forced to finance their endeavor.

One need not be a fervent environmentalist to see the problem here. At stake is not this single issue of Alaskan polar bears, but rather the entire premise that scientific theory founded on conclusions first and manufactured evidence second is equally valid as investigation done with the proper relationship.

Sphere: Related Content

Supporting the Troops Through No-Bid Contracts

Previously, I've discussed the government's commitment to supporting the troops by failing to test their body armor and equipment. Now comes more indication that, not only was the wiring in some US facilities in Iraq and Afghanistan an electrocution risk, but the government was informed of the risk and did nothing.

James Risen writes that as early as 2004, the Army warned its commanders that soldiers were at risk of electric shock due to faulty wiring installed by everyone's favorite Halliburton spin-off, KBR, which, of course, was granted no-bid contracts to do the work. Of equal clarity is that its being a subsidiary of Dick Cheney's old company is pure coincidence and the contract was awarded on merit alone. Without competition.

"We've had several shocks in showers and near misses here in Baghdad, as well as in other parts of the country," Frank Trent, an expert with the Army Corps of Engineers, wrote in the bulletin [entitled "The Unexpected Killer," {and} issued after the deaths of two soldiers.] "As we install temporary and permanent power on our projects, we must ensure that we require contractors to properly ground electrical systems."

Since that warning, at least two American soldiers have been electrocuted in similar incidents. In all, at least a dozen American military personnel have been electrocuted in Iraq, according to the Pentagon and congressional investigators.

KBR has had no shortage of warnings regarding its death traps:

American electricians who worked for KBR, the Houston-based defense contractor that is responsible for maintaining American bases in Iraq and Afghanistan, said they repeatedly warned company managers and military officials about unsafe electrical work, which often was performed by poorly trained Iraqis and Afghans paid just a few dollars a day.

One electrician warned his KBR bosses in his 2005 letter of resignation that unsafe electrical work was "a disaster waiting to happen."

Another said he witnessed an American soldier in Afghanistan receiving a potentially lethal shock. A third provided e-mail messages and other documents showing he had complained to KBR and the government that logs were created to make it appear that nonexistent electrical safety systems were properly functioning.

KBR's commitment to under-paying its laborers and accepting shoddy work as a trade-off is nothing new, having avoided nearly $500 million dollars in payroll taxes by hiring its employees through shell companies. But who needs shell companies when there's ample cheap labor and no regulations in Iraq and Afghanistan?

And lest we think that the warnings were just the work of a few disgruntled ex-employees:

KBR itself told the Pentagon in early 2007 about unsafe electrical wiring at a base near the Baghdad airport, but no repairs were made. Less than a year later, a soldier was electrocuted in a shower there.

So, if you're keeping up with the timeline, KBR and army commanders were aware of a problem by late 2004 (at least), it took until early 2007 for them to admit it, and having done nothing to rectify the problem allow another soldier to die.

Aside from the fraudulent, no-bid contracts granted to a company connected to the Vice President, contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan are only minimally accountable to the US government. Or any government, for that matter. Essentially, they answer to no one, as proven by Blackwater's seeming immunity, even in the face of massacring innocent, unarmed civilians.

As in the case of sending untested body armor to combat troops, allowing work that is known to be faulty and dangerous to go un-rectified does not mesh with the mantra of 'supporting the troops.' Rhetorical flourish aside, when it comes time to perform a duty to protect American soldiers from harm, and you fail, you no longer can hide behind the flag. KBR was warned, did nothing, and soldiers continued to die. KBR executives can slap a yellow ribbon on--or a flag pin--but it won't wash American blood off their hands.

Sphere: Related Content

Hillary Competing With McCain to See Who Can Get Caught in Reversals More Often

(Hat tip: Parisgnome)

Democrats, including Hillary Clinton, have been tripping over themselves in using John McCain's '100 years' comment against him. As I said before, to do so requires a very loose relationship with literacy.

McCain's backtracking is well-evidenced, and now it seems Clinton is not simply content to narrow the gap between them by adopting his proposals or threatening to 'obliterate' Iran. (Yes, Hillary, people that aren't Ahmadinejad live there, too. About 66 million of them.) No, she is also striving to pass him in the number of times someone can find contradictions in the public record.

Parisgnome at Daily Kos dug up this gem from a 2005 visit to Face the Nation on CBS:

SCHIEFFER: Well, what do you mean `long time'? Do you mean years?

[...]

Sen. CLINTON: Senator McCain made the point earlier today, which I agree with, and that is, it's not so much a question of time when it comes to American military presence for the average American; I include myself in this.

But it is a question of casualties. We don't want to see our young men and women dying and suffering these grievous injuries that so many of them have.

We've been in South Korea for 50-plus years. We've been in Europe for 50-plus. We're still in Okinawa with respect to protection there coming out of World War II. You know, we have been in places for very long periods of time.

[...]

But so is our understanding that if we were to artificially set a deadline of some sort, that would be like a green light to the terrorists, and we can't afford to do that.

Barack Obama's greatest weapon against Clinton has been her 2002 vote to authorize the Iraq War (easy for him since he wasn't there, of course.) In response, her campaign has held that it was a vote based on faulty intelligence and she shouldn't be held accountable, but as her visit with Bob Schieffer illustrates, she held McCain's outlook on the occupation well past when the intelligence aspect's ship had sailed.

The question, then, is which version is more true to her core beliefs. I tend to side with the 2005 incarnation, as I have always held that on foreign policy--obviously not domestic social issues--Clinton is right-leaning. The conservative outcry against her husband's interventions in Bosnia, Kosovo, Somalia, Haiti and Iraq (and her subsequent adoption of his Presidency as her own) can't be forgotten. I don't know that Clinton could be painted as a dove (relative to center, not Lieberman and McCain), no matter how hard Sean Hannity might try. Her plan for withdrawal now--a duplicate of Obama's 16-month plan--is merely borne of the realization that no Democrat was going to win that party's nomination calling for sustaining the occupation.

Sam Stein asked for a response from the campaign, and Phil Singer responded: "As both Senator Clinton and Senator Obama have noted, the situation in Iraq has dramatically deteriorated since 2005 and now we are in the midst of sectarian violence."

This response is ludicrous in that it suggests that the insurgency began after her appearance, which is outright false. Consider the lead-in to her Face the Nation appearance:

SCHIEFFER: And we start this morning with Kimberly Dozier, who is in Baghdad, where there were some awful bombings yesterday, but today fairly quiet. What's the latest, Kimberly?

KIMBERLY DOZIER reporting: Fairly quiet, but people are still holding funerals from yesterday's attacks and Friday's. Almost 100 people were killed and more than 100 wounded in a series of suicide bombings targeting Shiite worshipers marking the annual holiday of Ashura. That is to mark the prophet Muhammad's grandson's death. Now there were worse attacks last year; almost 200 people died. This year there was greater security, but suicide bombers still managed to mingle in with the crowd and, as the religious leaders have been saying here, tried to make the attacks that would turn Shiites against Sunnis. Religious leaders are trying to keep that from happening. Bob.

SCHIEFFER: So Baghdad is still a very dangerous place.

[...]

Senator Clinton, it seems there's still more violence going on in Iraq. How do you sum up the situation now?

CLINTON: [...] The violence that preceded the election was about 50 to 60 incidents a day. Leading up to the election, it rose all the way to 300, and now it has subsided again to, unfortunately, about 50 or 60 a day.

Clearly, there is no way that her campaign can make the case that violence wasn't an issue at the time of her appearance. Their response can only be based on the presumption that no one would review the historical record, which is consistent with their campaign tactics thus far.

I already thought the '100 years' attacks of McCain were loosely based on what he said, but now it is even more clear that for Hillary to use the attack against him is the height of revisionism and hypocrisy.

Sphere: Related Content