Tuesday, April 15, 2008

I Stand Corrected

Apparently, there are still at least a couple of journalists or pundits out there who understand the concept of delegates and their central role in the nominating process.

Given 24 hours to continuously banter for 6 weeks about a single Democratic Primary vote in Pennsylvania would allow for at least a minimal amount of time to devote to the actual process. Alas, it hasn't. What, with constantly searching for the next non-controversy to stoke continuously until, Presto!, you can say people care. No, actually looking at the process itself requires a small bit of research, and who wants to waste time with that when there's endless repetition of things other people say for you to drone on about.

Thankfully, Greg Giroux and Jonathan Allen at CQPolitics have taken the time so the talking heads won't have to.

That answer will be mainly determined not by the sum of the votes Clinton and Obama win in Pennsylvania, but rather by the state’s parts. Pennsylvania will send 187 Democratic delegates to the party’s national convention in Denver this August, and most of them — 103 to be exact — will be allocated according to the votes the candidates receive in each of the state’s 19 congressional districts.

And a CQ Politics analysis of the political circumstances in Pennsylvania’s congressional districts, detailed below, projects an edge to Clinton — but by just 53 district-level delegates to 50 for Obama under the Democratic Party’s proportional distribution rules.

These numbers suggest that Clinton, even with a victory in Pennsylvania, would make only a small incremental gain against Obama’s overall lead in the delegate race.

Of the state’s remaining 84 slots, only 55 pledged delegates will be distributed based on the statewide popular vote, with the state’s remaining 29 seats going to unpledged “superdelegates.”


As is made clear by the authors' breakdowns between the 19 congressional districts, the margin of victory is only important in a PR sense, and bears little effect of the outcome in terms of delegates. For the 103 delegates divvied up by district voting, the margin of victory needed to obtain more than a single delegate more than the opponent is essentially prohibitive. Giroux and Allen speaking of 4-delegate districts, of which there are 5: "So if Clinton defeats Obama 60 percent to 40 percent, the district delegates would split 2-2; if Obama defeats Clinton 60 percent to 40 percent, a 2-2 split would also ensue." Likewise, in a 5-delegate district, 70 percent of the vote would be needed to have a split other than 3-2.

Giroux and Allen continue in a detailed, district-by-district analysis and prediction (they arrive at Clinton 53, Obama 50). But the main point here is that even if they're off slightly--even completely inverse in most districts--the results won't change much unless one candidate absolutely trounces the other, which is implausible.

Even the 55 delegate divided by state-wide vote won't lend Clinton that large a margin. A 55-45 split for Clinton would yield her 30 delegates to Obama's 25. Even a highly-unlikely 60-40 divide would grant a 33-22 mix.

Given that a 20-point margin of victory is highly improbable, a best case scenario for Hillary would have her walking away from Pennsylvania with around a net gain of 10, perhaps 15, delegates. Not nearly enough to cover a margin of over 100.

Assuming Clinton wins Pennsylvania (a safe assumption at this point), the fact remains that nothing will change other than feeding fundraising and continued campaigning. A victory in the popular vote may help morale, but it is clearly not going to gloss over the fact that she is all-but mathematically eliminated from the race and has been for several months.

Sphere: Related Content

Jon Stewart Takes 9 Minutes to Detail Everything Wrong With Today's Political Coverage



While we're at it, all Obama said was people have been lied to on the economy so long that they vote on different values or single issues. Nowhere did he say only bitter people are religious. I know it's fun to get outraged, and feigned offense is the oil that lubricates the political machine, but it'd be nice if a little comprehension skill were employed along the way.

Sphere: Related Content

Monday, April 14, 2008

Tortured Logic

If there's one thing the War on Terror has made unambiguous, it's that ambiguity will continue to surround the actions of the United States and the Bush administration in its attempt to prevent further attacks upon the nation. Faced with preserving rights or preserving the ability of government to take those rights, Bush always sides with the latter, be it ever-growing surveillance powers or the use of torture in interrogations.

All too often, the administration is allowed to toss around misleading statements and outright falsehoods in the pursuit of those aims, and just as often cable news networks with 24 hours of space to fit questioning of the process fail miserably to that end. When the Attorney General was making up implausible scenarios in San Francisco, the news was centered on Barack Obama's inability to bowl. When the leader of the free world admitted that he knew and approved of violations of international and domestic law, the media wrapped itself in a blanket of despair over perceived elitism. From the poorest (relative term, of course) and least-established of the three candidates, no less.

What began years ago as "a few bad apples" participating in a sophomoric lapse in judgment has been fleshed out into full-fledged human rights violations under the umbrella of international and domestic statutes. And the media couldn't be less impressed.

As time has progressed from March of 2004, so has the overwhelming mountain of evidence pointing ever higher in the administration in search of the origins of the use of torture in US interrogation techniques. But, until Friday, there was nothing to link President Bush directly to the negotiations and planning. Those who thought such a revelation would portend some sort of culmination were sorely disappointed, as the country ignored the news with the same callous disregard in which Bush delivered it.

For the leader of a free nation to be admitting freely, without any hesitation or outwards sign of guilt, that he had full knowledge of his surrogates planning to break the law and be greeted with a shrug is nothing short of breathtaking.

First, it is important to emphasize that there is a definition of torture under US Code. It is a legal definition, not something which Bush or John Yoo get to manipulate with shifty words or maneuvering.

Sec. 2340. Definitions

As used in this chapter--
(1) "torture" means an act committed by a person acting under
the color of law specifically intended to inflict severe physical or
mental pain or suffering (other than pain or suffering incidental to
lawful sanctions) upon another person within his custody or physical
control;
(2) "severe mental pain or suffering" means the prolonged
mental harm caused by or resulting from--
(A) the intentional infliction or threatened infliction of
severe physical pain or suffering;
(B) the administration or application, or threatened
administration or application, of mind-altering substances or
other procedures calculated to disrupt profoundly the senses or
the personality;
(C) the threat of imminent death; or
(D) the threat that another person will imminently be
subjected to death, severe physical pain or suffering, or the
administration or application of mind-altering substances or
other procedures calculated to disrupt profoundly the senses or
personality; and

(3) "United States" means the several States of the United
States, the District of Columbia, and the commonwealths,
territories, and possessions of the United States.


Waterboarding has been the most-discussed method of interrogation (though the administration admits to using it on only 3 prisoners), and despite the rhetorical side-stepping of Bush and his appointees, it clearly meets the criteria of "'servere mental pain or suffering' resulting from threat of imminent death." There is really no way being made to feel as though drowning does not constitute 'threat of death.'

Yet, the act is still presented as an unclear procedure which may or may not be wrong, although any discussion of the veracity of either position is typically centered on the personal feelings of those involved in the argument rather than an objective utilization of definitions. When asked if the US tortured prisoners, Bush assured us "the United States does not torture," but we have admissions that waterboarding was used and the clear-enough definition of 'torture' under US Code to compare it to. This isn't a matter of asking the participants if they think they did anything wrong. It's not a matter of semantics. All that is required is a faithful adherence to the English language.

But beyond waterboarding, those interrogation techniques--though not talked about--which are much more widely-used still meet the definition. Consider several of the commonly-used methods: deprivation of sleep, deprivation of senses, exposure to extreme temperatures, and electric shock. To contend that these techniques fail to meet the definition spelled out in the US Code strains credibility and illustrates a wanton disregard for objectivity.

The definition clearly defines torture as "causing mental harm through procedures calculated to disrupt profoundly the senses or the personality." The Geneva Conventions explicitly prohibit "violence to life and person," "outrages upon personal dignity," and "conditions exposing [prisoners] to contagion or infection." All of the previously-listed techniques meet one or more of those definitions.

So George Bush is free to say that the "United States does not torture," but it is equally fair for others to bring up the actual definition of the US Code he has sworn to uphold in claiming he's lying. It's not a matter of opinion whether or not these acts are torture. There are legal definitions, and they are all met.

The administration, of course, does all this under the umbrella of homeland security. You've gotta break a few eggs to stop all the terrorists attacks. This first requires the belief that a government that missed a massive attack spanning two presidencies is suddenly competent enough to act upon what some schmuck says in conditions designed precisely so he'll say anything to get out of them. But, that aside, this again begs the question: When did the Executive Branch become responsible for interpreting and re-writing the law?

All good intentions aside, if the laws need to be changed, get them changed. Through legislation, not back-room semantic mangling by a sycophant flunkie. As much as it pains me, I mostly think Bush is a somewhat pitiful, hopeless idealist. I don't believe him to be inherently evil. But one thing is clear, and that is that the United States has flouted international treaties it has promised to uphold--and expects other countries to uphold when detaining our soldiers--and its own code.

Bush often says that history will be the true judge of his presidency. Sadly for him, I think that's true, because we haven't reached the end of the line yet. For all its egregious acts and slaps in the face to representative democracy, this administration has proven time and again that something more scandalous always lurks just around the corner.

Sphere: Related Content

Tough Love, With Pillows

Americans have a peculiar habit of skipping from one concern to the next. That which fills hours of continuous coverage on Cable News today will be forgotten before the sun rises on tomorrow. Such is the case with corporate crime.

Back in 2002, George Bush was fully on board with the effort to crack down on shady accounting practices which brought down Enron and Arthur Anderson along with numerous other companies and not least of all the pensions of thousands of innocent employees.

Bush, upon signing the Sarbanes-Oxley Act in 2002:

This new law sends very clear messages that all concerned must heed. This law says to every dishonest corporate leader: you will be exposed and punished; the era of low standards and false profits is over; no boardroom in America is above or beyond the law.

[...]

Corporate misdeeds will be found and will be punished. This law authorizes new funding for investigators and technology at the Securities and Exchange Commission to uncover wrongdoing. The SEC will now have the administrative authority to bar dishonest directors and officers from ever again serving in positions of corporate responsibility. The penalties for obstructing justice and shredding documents are greatly increased. Corporate crime will no longer pay. CEOs who profit by betraying the public trust will be forced to return those gains to investors. And the maximum prison term for common types of fraud has quadrupled from five to 20 years.

[...]

This law gives my administration new tools for enforcement. We will use them to the fullest. We will continue to investigate, arrest and prosecute corporate officials who break the law. The Corporate Fraud Task Force I established is now hard at work, overseeing investigations of alleged fraud and insider trading. More than 200 federal prosecutors are at work detecting and punishing corporate crimes. Every corporate official who has chosen to commit a crime can expect to face the consequences. No more easy money for corporate criminals, just hard time.


Sounds good enough. Corporate accountants risk jail time for playing fast and loose with the all-too-precarious futures of shareholders and employees. Increased SEC scrutiny and audits. All around, promises that major collapses like those of 2001 and 2002 would never happen again.

But, as is often the case, Americans moved on. They moved on to more inane celebrity gossip, got wrapped up in whatever reality show was popular at the moment, or occasionally paid attention to a fleeting political faux-scandal. But mostly, they lost interest. And the tide moved out. Almost immediately.

President Bush's utilization of signing statements to undermine the effectiveness of the bills he signs into law--often effectively nullifying them entirely--is no secret. The corporate crime bill was no exception, as Bush eliminated a provision to protect whistle blowers who bring to light violations by companies not already under investigation. In other words, at the same time he was declaring a new tough stance against corporate crime, President Bush was working to ensure that the process of prosecution would be stamped out at its root.

From there, many of the other mechanisms intended to prevent another catastrophic corporate malfeasance were rolled back or put on the back burner. Kim Clark details many of those efforts in this April, 2006 article in US News. Among other things, Clark details the elimination of SEC oversight positions and illuminates the first glimpse of what would become a theme later, saying "Since 2004, federal prosecutors have struck at least nine deals with companies accused of accounting fraud, to defer prosecution or not prosecute at all. In the previous five years, the Justice Department announced just four, according to the Corporate Crime Reporter."

But that jump--from 4 over 5 years to 9 over 16 months--in deferred prosecutions was but the tip of the iceberg, as Eric Lichtblau reveals in the New York Times.

In a major shift of policy, the Justice Department, once known for taking down giant corporations, including the accounting firm Arthur Andersen, has put off prosecuting more than 50 companies suspected of wrongdoing over the last three years.

Instead, many companies, from boutique outfits to immense corporations like American Express, have avoided the cost and stigma of defending themselves against criminal charges with a so-called deferred prosecution agreement, which allows the government to collect fines and appoint an outside monitor to impose internal reforms without going through a trial. In many cases, the name of the monitor and the details of the agreement are kept secret.


While the fines levied still carry a modicum of determent by punishment, it is not nearly the substantial and public retribution promised by Bush in 2002. Bush didn't say that corporate misdeeds would merely be met with fines, he promised purveyors of magic accounting and other corporate malpractice would be greeted with "hard time."

Consider, though, that many of those shady accounting practices have made their way into today's economic framework. Much of the attention is payed to inability to pay mortgages, which decidedly misses the point. The failure of a company like Bear Stearns stemmed from lax corporate oversight which allowed companies to take poor investments (sub-prime mortgages) and pass them off further and further up the chain until the system simply couldn't handle it anymore.

And once again, it's the employees of that company that bear the brunt of the fallout. Much is made of the use of federal funds to back JP Morgan's buyout, but nary a peep about the employees whose shares were bought for $2. They pay the price with their retirement plans.

Faced with an economic downturn strongly tied to dishonest and creative accounting practices, withholding of the shaky foundations of investments, and active pushing of disastrous mortgage agreements, attention needs to be given to the role that lax oversight played.

Corporations, like children, only understand and respond to consequenses, not words. Bush spoke strongly six years ago, but his actions illustrated to accountants and bankers that they would be mostly free to practice business as usual. Deferred prosecution agreements instilled an accurate perception that shady practices could be persued with a virtual guarantee that if caught a company would be greeted with a slap on the wrist and a fine.

Proponents of these agreements say they work to "avoid the type of company-wide havoc seen most acutely in the case of Arthur Anderson." While there certainly is credence to that--bringing a company to its knees (along with its innocent employees) out of a sense of retribution does more harm than good--it effectively, as we've seen in the mortgage scene, kicks the can down the road.

Prosecuting every wrongdoing with the zeal required by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act is probably impractical, but simply laying the foundation for a regulation/oversight-free environment that comes back to bite the country cannot be a reliable substitute.

Also, those suggesting that every prosecution would wreak havoc must explain the discrepancy in numbers. Jumping from 4 deferred prosecutions over 5 years to more than 50 over three years and 35 last year alone requires explanation stretching the bounds of credibility. The implication of disaster doesn't sync with the fact that prior to the Bush administration these agreements were rare without a simultaneous rash of company failures. The reality, once again, fails to support the administration's factual maneuvering.

Deferred prosecution agreements on the scale that the Justice Department has utilized them in recent years is indicitive of a larger picture. A picure painted with broad strokes of lax regulation, failure to employ oversight, and attempts to stymie investigations at their very root. Failure on this scale has allowed an entire segment of the economy to be propped up on a foundation of popsicle sticks. Sadly, it's not an accident. The economic issues created by the poor investment practices of the banking industry are a direct result of the nod-and-wink relationship it has with the Bush administration.

Sphere: Related Content